The garden structure — pergola, arbor, trellis — is one of the few elements in the traditional New England landscape that is entirely constructed rather than cultivated. It frames views, supports plants, provides shade, and marks transitions in the garden. It is also one of the elements most commonly built incorrectly, from wood that cannot survive a New England climate without paint or constant maintenance.
A correct pergola in a traditional New England garden reads as a structure that belongs to the same material vocabulary as the house — painted white if the house trim is white, natural cedar if the building is shingled and unpainted, or black locust if longevity without maintenance is the specification. The members are heavy enough to read as structural — 4x4 or 6x6 posts, 2x6 or 2x8 beams, 2x4 or 2x6 rafters.
Wood species for garden structures in a New England context: white cedar and black locust for unpainted natural structures; clear white pine for painted structures. Douglas fir is acceptable for painted structures where clear pine is unavailable in large dimensions. Pressure-treated pine is correct for post bases in ground contact but incorrect for visible framing above grade.
White cedar weathers to grey and holds its structural integrity for 20 to 40 years in above-grade conditions. Black locust in above-grade conditions lasts indefinitely. Clear white pine, correctly primed and painted, lasts as long as the paint is maintained. Pressure-treated pine above grade weathers poorly without paint and checks aggressively.
The garden structure is a significant investment and it should be built from material that matches its intended life and maintenance approach. A painted pergola built from pressure-treated pine fails visually almost immediately — the checking and the green tint of the preservative read through paint.
White cedar and black locust from regional sawmills and specialty lumber dealers. Clear white pine from lumber yards that stock 5/4 and heavier dimensions. For painted structures, prime all wood on all faces before assembly.
Northern white cedar or black locust for unpainted garden structures; clear eastern white pine, back-primed, for painted garden structures. Minimum 4x4 posts, 2x6 beams. Mortised or half-lapped joinery at connections. No pressure-treated pine above grade. The structure should be built from New England wood by someone who understands how New England wood behaves.
Something missing from the archive?
Suggest a material →